Please note that my Critic is not my Inner Editor; my Editor and I get along really well most of the time. She is a kindly young schoolteacher who uses a blue, green or purple pen (never a red one). She waits patiently for me to turn in assignments more often than she hangs over me, reading as I write. She wears postwar 40's sundresses with a scattering of chiffon flowers, sensible shoes, and a straw hat when she goes walking. I enjoy working with her.
On the other hand, I am trying to work out some kind of mind time-share, or possibly a professional barter with my Critic. My Critic is a dark and evil shadow. She looks like I would look if I was an anorexic corporate lawyer. Her conservative suits are expensive and stunningly tailored over a perfect figure. Her fingernails and high heels are dangerous weapons in daring colors. Her sharp cheek and collar bones allow her to cut through any defense. She is always right. I revere her, because she fights my battles, as a good lawyer must, but I long for a relationship with her that is symbiotic instead of parasitic.
Parasitic, you ask? Yes. As averse to food as her anorexia has made her, she vampirically sucks up the positive feedback that comes my way. Here's what she ate this week:
"I loved your article. Very inspiring, entertaining and well-written."
"Yeehaw! That was a rollicking good time! wonderful revisions, Yvette...How could anyone fail to feel the thrill of joining in NoNoWriMo after that? So great. Let me know when there's a link to the online 'zine! I'll pass it around."
I'm happy to receive all this praise, and yet the warm, suffusing glow of pride and self-love lasts a fraction of a moment. My Critic sucks it away:
"What do they know? Why would you trust THEIR opinions? It wasn't that great. It needed more work. It was sloppy. I'm sure you missed something. I'm sure you spelled something wrong, changed tense mid paragraph, mixed your metaphors and left behind evidence they can use to convict us. They will find out we can't write. They will see we are merely pretending...and they will GET YOU. *I* can hardly do EVERYTHING around here! Work harder! Be better! Stop being blind and stupid and making messes!"
Seriously, she is the meanest bitch on the planet. And she is undoubtedly me.
How can I work with someone so toxic? In the past, I just let her drain away all the compliments. Sated for the moment, she would lick them from her lips and merely remind me to BE CAREFUL.
I believe I am ready to stop feeding her, but I don't know how. I believe that if I kept some of those kind words for myself and my hardworking Inner Editor, we would be more prolific. Certainly we wouldn't have to scrounge in secret for a guilty slice of ciabatta, covered in leftover sharp goat chèvre and sweet fig jam. We could picnic together on praise, and toast our hard work with distilled encouragement to make ourselves feel better.
I've got to find a way to kick my Critic habit; pull her from the pedestal and bar her from the bar. Convince her I am not on trial all the time.
I need to retire her permanently to a far away not-for-profit. Send her to fight a useful battle. Make her feel great about what she does, and write her lots of thank you cards and love notes.
Maybe that would even work...she's damn smart. I need her. She snaps me out of any tendency toward complacency...but maybe I don't need her all the time.